{
  "date": "2026-10-22",
  "accepted_device_cards": {
    "selected_sensing_energy_saving_pct": 23.04,
    "phone_input_power_scenario_saving_pct": 4.61,
    "recording_storage_saving_pct": 19.97
  },
  "adoption_decision": "Retain accepted R13 numerical cards. Add a concise 22 October research update behind an evidence link. Today's audited findings do not establish a new cumulative whole-device gain over the strongest attainable ordinary comparison.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "energy_storage_r5",
      "boundary": "SERVICE_AND_ASSUMPTIONS_R5.md",
      "revision": "R5",
      "status_at_freeze": "Executed conditional simulation; sealed independent critic verdict pending. Latest chat says critic matched frozen hashes and outputs and accounted for all 120 IDs, with seven analogous requirements and 113 having no direct requirement transfer.",
      "service": "Assumed 12 V cyclic actuator: 400 J lowering and 400 J lifting, each 5 seconds, 90 second period; same mechanical service and restored battery/capacitor energy endpoints. Four 100 F cells form a 25 F series buffer. Comparison uses ordinary battery regeneration; charge acceptance is an explicit assumed boundary.",
      "result_pct_grid_energy": {
        "12W_acceptance_nominal": 30.014228314413398,
        "adverse": 18.756211068704907,
        "intermediate_acceptance": 15.488683542207355,
        "64W_acceptance": -6.469258954541343
      },
      "pins_sha256": {
        "builder/model_r4.py": "5dcd60163b8ad56d6e947c9a1f7293eedd72718228d5431755e71bf19be422df",
        "builder/cases_frozen_r5.json": "98444fd41f145afd3fc9644f3e353c74f77b2a229885ff00b70b4480e5a1135f",
        "builder/run_r5_raw.json": "4dbcb7b8b23101af7f0d3b453771788dda155d420783c810f70e8fe309dcb726"
      },
      "receipt": "builder/RUN_RECEIPT_R5_EXACT.json; PID 50212; exit 0; empty stderr",
      "primary_sources": [
        "https://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/lm5170.pdf",
        "https://www.ti.com/lit/gpn/bq33100",
        "https://maxwell.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/3003123-EN2_ds_Std.-2.7V-100F_20200908.pdf"
      ],
      "superseded": "Earlier 34.3%, 32.2%, 24.5%, 23.1%, -1.1% and -2.6% figures precede endpoint/controller repairs and must not replace R5.",
      "marketing_recommendation": "Research detail only: Capturing a braking pulse can cut energy use when the battery cannot absorb it. In the assumed lift cycle, the buffer saves 30.01% grid energy at a 12 W battery charge limit; at 64 W acceptance it uses 6.47% more. State review-pending status once. Do not put the percentage on the homepage or attribute it to the FI 120-reference portfolio.",
      "source_record": "HANDOFF_R1.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "power_components_r5",
      "status": "Conditional checkpoint, critic complete; independent R5 rerun byte identical.",
      "service": "Standalone isolated 24 V/20 A, 480 W AC/DC supply at 230 VAC for 24 h; useful output exported outside PSU thermal boundary; assumed 2 W fan equal in both cases.",
      "result": {
        "supply_local_heat_saving_pct_vs94_5baseline": 20.2794,
        "input_energy_saving_pct_vs94_5baseline": 1.1903,
        "heat_saving_pct_vs95baseline": 12.4622,
        "heat_saving_pct_vs95_5baseline": 3.0557,
        "reference_efficiency_ceiling_for10pct_local_heat": 0.951404
      },
      "hold_up": {
        "service_ms": 10,
        "capacitors": "Seven TDK B43652B5477M050, 470 uF/450 V",
        "nominal_uF": 3290,
        "effective_uF_after_minus20pct_tolerance_and_assumed10pct_aging": 2368.8,
        "available_J": 7.428432,
        "required_J": 4.977188,
        "capacitor_circles_mm2": 6735
      },
      "pins_sha256": {
        "builder/ASSUMPTIONS_R5.json": "f0f7f52df4beebe5f49d05b9efe8e1a30aafd336891bebfe7273c8eb6d109144",
        "builder/PARTS_R5.json": "c4775387ed7c40e2952a84757046b90eafd3e96824cc22def1f7a9dec330eea5",
        "critic/VERDICT_R5.json": "1449bd077a90b887161019945eb6e876ba59cf9064c6405ee52d4db7ab96c0dd",
        "builder/RUN_R2.json": "be00425a0f95a4e0f000cafddde6363971e235af1727e88e9760d159cb45ca74"
      },
      "primary_sources": [
        "https://www.ti.com/tool/TIDA-010015",
        "https://www.ti.com/lit/ug/tidt033/tidt033.pdf",
        "https://www.tdk-electronics.tdk.com/inf/20/30/db/aec/b43652.pdf"
      ],
      "material_tradeoffs": "Capacitor circles occupy about 52.62% of an illustrative 160x80 mm board. TI dimensions conflict with another published footprint; no placement verified. Full candidate AC/DC loss, hot behavior, ripple, inrush and protection remain open. Modern unmatched 12 V conventional source reaches 96.44%; strongest matched 24 V reference remains unresolved.",
      "superseded": "R4 nominal 2000 uF hold-up passed before tolerance; critic found low-tolerance failure. R5 is current.",
      "marketing_recommendation": "Supporting research detail: A supply model cuts local heat by 20.28% against a 94.5%-efficient reference, equivalent to 1.19% less input energy. The seven-capacitor bank meets the modeled 10 ms hold-up requirement; physical fit and complete losses remain open. Do not transfer local heat to whole-device heat or claim smaller/lighter hardware.",
      "source_record": "HANDOFF_R2.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "system_consolidation_r2",
      "handoff_sha256": "9d26e88450ed8d2237633c62b899a6108296af8f680f9813b0191a97ff29da73",
      "status": "Executed bound checkpoint, unsealed. Critic rejected substantiated >=10% incremental gain; exact artifact readback failed.",
      "service": "Battery motion tag with continuous 100 Hz acceleration, BLE and IEEE 802.15.4 reports; independent simultaneous reception and chip-fault survival tested separately.",
      "result": {
        "60s_reporting_optimistic_two_chip_saving_pct": 13.95708,
        "60s_reporting_nominal_two_chip_saving_pct": 8.93974,
        "strong_ordinary_TI_DMM_incremental_saving_pct": 0,
        "one_RF_overlap_test": "fails",
        "single_chip_fault_survival": "fails"
      },
      "pins_sha256": {
        "model_r2.py": "9125d4a60b695fb650cea831726b24c1ce254bb52549df5f671c201aece58417",
        "MODEL_RESULTS_R2.json": "0debdc22e29ac104750123528d92c104a010987c6a48264eb0e8ecc50b62b929",
        "critic/CRITIC_VERDICT_R1.json": "c62370f6e9f18caec885b2d56391777384a2cc1532bba5dc2de9e3954e3944c7"
      },
      "primary_source": "https://software-dl.ti.com/simplelink/esd/simplelink_cc13xx_cc26xx_sdk/7.40.00.77/exports/docs/dmm/dmm_user_guide/html/dmm/scheduling.html",
      "marketing_recommendation": "Useful design choice, no headline gain: Shared control reduces duplicated parts when radio windows can be scheduled. The ordinary TI one-chip design gives the same modeled energy; simultaneous reception and independent fault survival require separate RF paths. Keep ordinary tie visible once.",
      "source_record": "HANDOFF_R1.json"
    }
  ]
}